Steven Mosher is an English major with a long career in marketing and
technology who is known for wasting everyone's time by making
indecipherable
drive-by comments on skeptic websites. He is not an "
aerospace engineer", he is not an "
open-source software developer" and he is certainly not a "
scientist" (despite all
ridiculous claims to the contrary).
"Mosh[er] is indeed a scientist..." - Willis Eschenbach
Unlike
apparently most of those who entertain his comments I took the time to
research Mr. Mosher's credentials and found them long but completely
devoid of any scientific education or experience.
Steven M. Mosher,
B.A. English, Northwestern University (1981);
Teaching Assistant, English Department, UCLA (1981-1985); Director of Operations Research/Foreign Military Sales &
Marketing, Northrop Corporation [Grumman] (1985-1990); Vice President of Engineering [
Simulation], Eidetics International (1990-1993); Director of
Marketing, Kubota Graphics Corporation (1993-1994); Vice President of Sales &
Marketing, Criterion Software (1994-1995);
Vice President of Personal Digital Entertainment, Creative Labs (1995-2006);
Vice President of Marketing, Openmoko (2007-2009); Founder and CEO, Qi Hardware Inc. (2009);
Marketing Consultant (2010-2012);
Vice President of Sales and Marketing, VizzEco Inc. (2010-2011); [
Marketing] Advisor, RedZu Online Dating Service (2012-2013);
Advisory Board, urSpin (n.d.); Team Member, Berkeley Earth 501C(3) Non-Profit Organization unaffiliated with UC Berkeley (2013-Present)
Ironically, the #1 word that appears on his
LinkedIn profile is
Marketing.
Since
he has been a frequent commentator on various climate related websites
[Climate Audit, Climate Etc., The Blackboard and Watts Up With That?]
his status has grown into somewhat of an
urban legend. Yet, he is only notable in the global warming debate for two main things:
1. Writing a book on the Climategate scandal in 2010 - "
Climategate: The Crutape Letters" and,
2.
Outing Peter Gleick over the fake Heartland Institute Memo in 2012.
While
both are legitimate, neither has anything to do with scientific
research and both lend to his English language skills. The problem with
trying to determine his education and experience is his background
changes depending on the source and various positions and titles appear
to have evolved over time.
Background Inconsistencies and Misrepresentations
Sometimes it appears even Mr. Mosher does not know who he is.
* In a March of 2012
resume Mr. Mosher posted to Indeed.com he claims to have a "
Ph.D. in English" but in an
interview in 1999 he explicitly stated, "
I quit my Ph.D. in English to become a full time operational analyst."
 |
| Source: Steven Mosher Resume posted to Indeed.com |
* Depending on the source Mr. Mosher's degree from Northwestern University reinvents itself:
"
B.A. English Literature and Philosophy"
"
B.A. Philosophy and English"
"
Philosophy, Linguistics"
"
B.A. English"
Northwestern University does not offer majors in "
English Literature and Philosophy", "
Philosophy and English or "
Philosophy, Linguistics"
so these appear to be embellishments on his English degree. If he did
receive a double major or multiple degrees at Northwestern University he
would have made sure to mention this but never does. (Update: this is now mentioned on his LinkedIn Profile)
* Mr. Mosher's
profile for urSpin claims that he was a "
Professor at UCLA" but an
online profile he posted states he was just a "
Teaching Assistant".
* In an October of 2013
comment at Climate Etc., Mr. Mosher claimed that, "
between 1985 and 1993 I worked as an aerospace engineer." Yet, in an
interview in 1999 he stated his work related to
war gaming and flight simulators during this time. He even played the title of his position at Northrop down, "
An old college buddy from Northwestern got me a summer internship at Northrop Aircraft, doing operational analysis. That's a fancy term for war gaming."
* Mr. Mosher's title of "
Vice President of Engineering" at Eidetics International is misleading since one of his
online profiles claims he was "
Vice President of Simulation" and "
Designed Flight Simulators". This is confirmed by
U.S. Department of Defense Grants
he received during this time specifically relating to flight
simulators. A departmental title like this is also relatively
insignificant at smaller companies with only
40 employees like Eidetics International.
* The
bio for Mr. Mosher's book claims, "
He
later joined Northrop Aircraft where he worked as an threat analyst and
director of analysis until transitioning to the commercial world in
1995 when he joined Creative Labs" but all of his
online profiles say he worked for Eidetics International, Kubota Graphics and Criterion Software between 1990 and 1995 after he left Northrop.
* Mr. Mosher appears to have held six or more titles during his 11-year career at Creative Labs which is rather unusual:
"
Director of Marketing and Product Development"
"
Director of Graphics Marketing"
"
Vice President of Emerging Technology"
"
Vice President of New Technology"
"
Vice President of Graphics Business Unit"
"
Vice President of Personal Digital Entertainment"
I was able to confirm that he was a
Vice President at Creative Labs and most likely the
Vice President of Personal Digital Entertainment
since he was representing Creative Labs at a technology conference in
2004 with this title but some of the others may have been manufactured.
* Mr. Mosher's
profile
at Vizzeco claims he was responsible for "launching the very first MP3
player". Yet, the first Creative Labs MP3 player the NOMAD was released
in
April of 1999, while companies like Diamond Multimedia had already released an MP3 player the RIO in
September of 1998 and the very first MP3 player the Saehan MPMan was released a year earlier in
March of 1998.
* In a January 2010 article at
Breitbart and in a February 2010 article in
The Guardian they both claim Mr. Mosher is an "
open-source software developer". Yet, in a March 2010
comment to DeSmogBlog Mr. Mosher stated he was actually only an "
open-source advocate".
These are two vastly different things, one is a profession the other is
a cheerleader. Mr. Mosher could have easily gotten this misinformation
corrected since he was also an
author at Breitbart but failed to do so.
* In a November 2010 article in the
New York Times it claims Mr. Mosher is a "
software developer" but there is no evidence of him ever being professionally employed in this role. On his
LinkedIn
profile under the self-appointed title of "Marketing Consultant" it is
claimed that he is an "R Software Developer" but this is a misnomer, as
there is no evidence of him writing new software applications using the R
programming language but rather he uses it to
analyze data. Ironically, in a March 2010
comment to DeSmogBlog he stated, "
I stopped writing code ages ago".
Climategate Role
Mr.
Mosher is frequently given far too much importance relating to
Climategate breaking in November of 2009 when actually he was akin
to a courier, being one of the first people who was given the hacked
emails by the WUWT moderator who found them,
Charles Rotter,
and only because they happened to be roommates at the time. The
anonymous hacker had posted an FTP link to multiple sites such as Warren
Myer's
Climate Skeptic, Patrick "Jeff" Condon's
The Air Vent and of course to Anthony Watt's
Watts Up With That?, none of which were to Mr. Mosher's blog which had been up since
June 2009. Despite
delusions of grandeur ["
Steven Mosher is to Climategate what Woodward and Bernstein were to Watergate"] and
ridiculous assertions ["
He
was just the right person, with just the right influence, and just the
right expertise to be at the heart of the promulgation of the files"]
Mr. Mosher was nothing more than a temporary go-between that he used to
inflate his importance in the matter. He was never directly contacted
or targeted by the anonymous hacker as a source to leak the emails since
he was not prominent in the climate skeptic community and it required
no special "expertise" to read emails, nor special "influence" to
contact people like Steve McIntyre. In the end it was Anthony Watts and
Charles Rotter who "
broke" the story at
WUWT where the anonymous hacker had originally intended. This did not stop Mr. Mosher from making
ridiculous claims to have "alerted the internet" to the Climategate emails.
Is he a Scientist?
It is rather odd that the Berkley Earth team would bestow upon Mr. Mosher the misleading title of "
Scientist" when he has clearly not earned it through education and experience.
He first appeared on the Berkley Earth website in July of 2012 as a "
Consultant" but an online profile he posted claims he started in January of 2012 as an "
Open Source Volunteer".
It seems once professional scientists climatologist
Dr. Judith Curry
and statistical scientist Dr. David Brillinger left the team in early
2013, he was quickly promoted to the title of "
Scientist"
but why? My emails to Berkley Earth asking for an explanation as to
what qualifies Mr. Mosher to the title of "Scientist" were not answered.
His
LinkedIn
profile claims he has been a "Scientist" with Berkley Earth since March
of 2013, which is the same time he was first listed as a co-author
(notably always last) for a couple of insignificant papers (
Rhode et al. 2013,
Wickham et al. 2013).
This is rather weak criteria, considering it would allow just about
anyone to use the title of "Scientist", including many graduate students
who may have assisted a professional scientist with research for a
paper and were rewarded with their name as a co-author. What is even
weaker is that his role with Berkley Earth by his own admission is one
of a technical nature similar to a data analyst not a scientist, "
I am currently writing and maintaining R code devoted to the Berkeley Earth Surface Temperature Project."
Sometimes the answer is rather simple. Since the founder of Berkeley Earth,
Richard A. Muller, is a
Professor of Physics
at the University of California Berkeley, it is incorrectly believed
that Berkeley Earth is affiliated with the University but further
research reveals that it is an independent 501C(3) Non-Profit
Organization
registered to a house
in Berkeley California and completely unaffiliated with UC Berkeley.
This gives the organization the facade of a scientific authority when in
reality they can fabricate whatever titles they feel like. If Berkeley
Earth wants to be taken seriously they should begin by not manufacturing
credentials for people who have clearly not earned them, as this does a
disservice to professional scientists who have put in the years earning
advanced degrees and doing scientific research at research institutions
and universities.
Mr. Mosher also conveniently appears to be the
main contact for the Berkeley Earth website and potentially maintains it.
In Conclusion
In the end, Mr. Mosher may be very good at marketing (especially himself) but the evidence clearly shows he is not a scientist.
Update 1
* In
response to a discussion about his background where all of my comments were censored at Climate Etc., Mr. Mosher links to a
technical paper
about flight simulators he co-authored while at Eidetics International.
The paper is redundant, as it has already been established in this
article that he worked on flight simulators at Eidetics International
and a technical paper on the results of "
flight simulator experiments" still does not make him an "aerospace engineer".
* Mr. Mosher also
claims to have been responsible for the artificial intelligence in a 1998 video game
Falcon 4.0 but his name does not appear anywhere in the
manual.
*
As an example of transparency and openness, Judith Curry
is extensively censoring my comments at her website Climate Etc. to
protect Mr. Mosher who cannot handle tough questions about his
background.
Update 2
As further evidence that he is not a professional software developer, Mr. Mosher lacks elemetary knowledge of the difference between the
Windows ME (Millennium) and Windows 2000 operating systems.
Rebuttals
Criticism: Anyone who follows the scientific method is a scientist.
Rebuttal: Claiming anyone can be a "scientist" makes the title meaningless. There is a big distinction between an amateur scientist and a professional scientist. A professional scientist is "
a person who is trained in a science and whose job involves doing scientific research or solving scientific problems." Since Mr. Mosher has no educational background or any professional experience as a scientist, the only thing he can be considered is an amateur scientist.
* scientist (defined) "
a person who is trained in a science and whose job involves doing scientific research or solving scientific problems" -
Merriam-Webster
* scientist (defined) "
someone who is trained in science, especially someone whose job is to do scientific research" -
Macmillan
